NOM BLOG

Monthly Archives: May 2011

IL Religious Adoption Agencies Push for Right to Help Kids

From the National Catholic Register:

Catholic leaders in Illinois are scrambling for a last-minute fix to prevent a showdown between the state and Catholic Charities of Illinois.

They want lawmakers to amend the state’s civil-union bill, set to take effect June 1, in order to assure that child welfare agencies such as Catholic Charities can continue turning down applications from cohabiting couples, whether homosexual or heterosexual.

“We want to see legislative action occur quickly so we can preserve our adoption and foster-care services for the thousands of children and families we serve,” said Carolyn Matheson, director of advancement for Catholic Charities of the Diocese of Peoria. “The spin is that we’re anti-gay, but that’s not true. We’re against cohabitation, regardless of sexual orientation, which is in keeping with Catholic teaching. We’re not denying anybody the right to adopt or serve as foster parents, but we’re not going to process such applications ourselves.”

Video: UM Law Grad Says Debating SSM Anymore is "Ridiculous"

More than 100 newly graduated lawyers walked out of their own graduation at the University of Michigan Law School on Saturday to protest the commencement speech by Ohio Sen. Rob Portman.

One newly-minted lawyer spoke about how she believes the law community is done debating issues as fundamental as marriage:

That's some education at work.

Portugal's 2009 Supreme Court Ruling: No Right to Gay Marriage

We were, until quite recently, unaware of this ruling (overshadowed perhaps by the legislature's decision to accept gay marriage).

Also, we don't speak Portugese.  Any readers who do?  Let us know!

Gay Author: People Who Believe in 1M1W Marriage Should Be Shamed

Candace Chellow-Hodge, author of "Bulletproof Faith: A Spiritual Survival Guide" and pastor of a United Church of Christ in South Carolina, writes at Religion Dispatches about the dignity she thinks defenders of marriage don't deserve:

"To win civil rights, one of the last steps is to make it shameful to be against the rights of the group fighting for recognition."

In this case, she means it must become "shameful" for people to believe that children deserve a mother and a father, and that marriage is between one man and one woman.

King & Spalding Tries To Explain Why They Dumped a Client

Every day we hear of more people dumping K&S for "cutting and running" --here's the firm's attempt at damage control:

The head of King & Spalding's Washington office is accepting blame for what he calls the "misunderstanding" that led the firm last month to accept, and then drop, the U.S. House of Representatives as a client in same-sex marriage litigation.

The statement by J. Sedwick "Wick" Sollers comes in a story today from The Daily Report, an Atlanta-based affiliate of The National Law Journal. The newspaper reports other new details about King & Spalding’s reversal, including that the firm’s client-vetting committee did not examine the House’s contract until after then-partner Paul Clement signed it.

 

On the March for Marriage! NOM Marriage News for May 12, 2011

Great news from New York! And Minnesota! And Rhode Island!

Last week NOM launched a Spanish-language radio ad featuring State Senator and Reverend Rubén Díaz and his call for a "March for Dignity" to defend marriage this Sunday in the Bronx.

Here's the ad with English subtitles:

Diaz event this Sunday

This week Rev. Díaz asked me if I would march with him on Sunday, and boy am I honored to say "yes"!

Brian to the Bronx for Marriage on Sunday! You can follow my tweets at http://twitter.com/NOMtweets and I'll come back with photos, video and a full report!

And this week NOM launched our own TV ad, "Consequences":

NY TV Ad on the Air Now

It's having an effect: Capital Confidential, a blog of the Albany Times-Union noticed, "It seemed like every commercial break in last night's broadcast of Capital Tonight contained this ad, released yesterday by the National Organization of Marriage."

And we announced a new pledge: $1.5 million for marriage in New York, including $500,000 for our current media buy and voter outreach and $1 million for the next election, to make sure citizens know how their representatives voted.

Gov. Andrew Cuomo

Here's what the Associated Press said: "Opponents of gay marriage in New York got national funding Tuesday as lobbyists, clergy, Gov. Andrew Cuomo and legislators head for a six-week legalization showdown with global implications.

"The $1.5 million pledged by the Washington-based National Organization for Marriage comes with the organization's expertise after recent success against same-sex marriage bills in Maryland, Rhode Island and in a New York congressional primary."

In the press release, I pointed out that we had defeated every Republican who voted for gay marriage we had ever targeted. More good news: A new Marist poll released yesterday shows the majority of New Yorkers oppose gay marriage, 53% to 46%; and it is New Yorkers of color who are leading the way, since 63% of them oppose gay marriage.

Plus, the poll shows 76% of New York Republicans think marriage should be only between one man and one woman.

I think we can keep NOM's record of unseating pro-gay-marriage Republicans intact if we need to in New York! Rev. Jason Maguire and New Yorkers for Constitutional Freedom's "Mayday for Marriage" bus tour is crisscrossing the state to rally the troops. Andrew Cuomo is also crisscrossing the state, trying to rally New Yorkers to pressure their legislators to pass his top three priorities: "legalization of same-sex marriage, ethics reform and a property tax cap," reports the New York Daily News. "This is a battle for the control of government," Cuomo said to a crowd of about 300 people at Onondaga Community College.

Well yes, Gov. Cuomo, it is--and when it comes to marriage you are on the wrong side of that battle!

This is sad for New Yorkers, because they need a governor who's totally focused on taming the budget and reviving the economy, not winning media accolades while alienating voters with his priorities. (I'm guessing the media is not going to release a poll, as they frequently did when the federal marriage amendment was the issue, asking voters what their top three priorities are and see how many New Yorkers say "gay marriage.")

Sen. Ruben Diaz

That was Sen. Díaz's point in his sharp public criticism of Gov. Cuomo's priorities. Díaz is a liberal Democrat from the Bronx, and his constituents have other priorities: "It is a shame that Governor Andrew Cuomo is using his efforts and the resources of the governor's office to push for homosexual marriage instead of saving New York's rent control and rent stabilization laws," Sen. Díaz said. "Governor Cuomo, please help New York's poor and needy people... instead of pushing for gay marriage!" Republican senators' constituents probably have different priorities that Sen. Díaz's, but in neither case is gay marriage high among them.

It is amazing to me how out-of-touch "star" politicians can be sometimes. If you only read the New York Times and talk to the Human Rights Campaign, you might believe opposition to gay marriage has crumbled. You might really imagine that you can rally people to your cause by making gay marriage the marquee issue. This fantasy is soon going to meet the reality, however.

For Gov. Cuomo it looks like already has. Breaking news from New York: Gov. Cuomo now says there may not be a floor vote on gay marriage at all. According to the AP: "'We want to pass a bill,' Cuomo said Wednesday. 'We don't want to bring up a bill in the Senate that would fail.'

"He said he won't put the bill to a vote "for the sake of a vote." That was the argument in 2009 by many optimistic advocates who thought bringing the issue to the floor would at least help the effort's momentum, and would force lawmakers to vote their conscience over politics. The surprising defeat in the Senate turned out to be a setback for gay marriage advocates nationwide."

I have so much more I could write to you about.

In Minnesota, a marriage amendment just passed the Senate by a vote of 38 to 27. Gay-marriage advocates are admitting it will likely pass the House too, giving the people of Minnesota a chance to decide the future of marriage in November 2012.

One Minnesotan wrote to the Star Tribune about the nasty, negative and sometime mean language many gay-marriage advocates are using there. "William Lemire writes to the Star Tribune:

I have heard many opponents of the marriage amendment accusing supporters (like me) of bigotry and mean-spiritedness. These accusations are not true; they are not intellectually honest; they are not just, and they do not productively advance the dialogue on this important debate."

He goes on to add:

"Is it genuine bigotry to believe that a child needs a father and a mother? Is it mean-spirited to believe that the legal institution of marriage is far more about children's and society's ultimate needs than it is about the emotions and desires of the wedded adults?

"Whatever our viewpoint, let's commit ourselves to a public debate worthy of honorable men and women nobly participating in a government of the people. To that end, let's allow those same honorable men and women to vote on the marriage amendment in November 2012."

Amen to that!

Victory in the MN Senate

Kudos to the Minnesota Family Council, Archbishop John C. Nienstedt, and the thousands of Minnesotans who wrote, phoned, and emailed to make sure their voices were heard! Thank you. You make impossible victories possible, over and over again.

Rhode Island had hearings on the civil unions bill being pushed by Speaker Gordon Fox after the gay marriage bill had to be pulled for lack of votes.

Our own Chris Plante was there and reported on the surreal event:

"No witnesses signed up to testify in favor of House Bill 6103. Many Committee members remarked that they received 1,000's of communications against this bill and none in favor. Nonetheless, bill sponsor Representative Petrarca stated he did not care that no one was in support of the bill. MERI Board President, Martha Holt, declared that she would be the first to volunteer to challenge the proposed civil unions legislation in court. GLAD attorney Karen Lowey agreed that court action is 'on the table.'"

NOM Rhode Island opposed the bill because it would invite the courts to strike down marriage, and creates serious risks to religious people, organizations, and small business owners.

Rhode Island's Hispanic Ministerial Alliance delivered 2000-plus signatures against the bill. On NOM's blog we posted this: "Breaking News from AP: Civil Unions Bill Flops in Rhode Island."

From the AP:

"A political compromise calling for the creation of civil unions in Rhode Island has drawn nothing but opposition during a public hearing in the Statehouse. ...

"Civil unions would grant the same state rights given to married couples in Rhode Island. The proposal was introduced after legislative leaders said gay marriage legislation lacked the votes to pass.

"The committee could decide as early as next week whether to advance the bill to the full House for consideration."

Many of you wrote to me to point out that Fox News's expert in psychiatry, Dr. Keith Ablow, wrote a column accusing marriage of being a source of suffering for the "vast majority" of married people, and a leading cause of depression.

Our own Maggie Gallagher went to war (her pen is her sword) against the incredible ignorance that column displayed:

Dr. Ablow further asserts, "without a doubt" (and also without evidence), that marriage is "one of the leading causes of major depression in the nation," and points to marriage's status as a legal union as a key cause. Because the law makes it harder to leave a marriage, marriage deprives men and women of what he calls "the joy of being 'chosen' on a daily basis." If marriage had no legal status, he states, marriages would feel "less confining."

Dr. Ablow has impressive credentials. His website calls him "one of America's leading psychiatrists," and an assistant professor at Tufts Medical School.

But when it comes to marriage, mental health and relationship quality, Dr. Ablow is blowing hot air.

You would never know from Dr. Ablow's column that an enormous quantity of social science has gone into investigating the relationships between marriage and mental health, especially depression, and also into comparing relationship quality between cohabiting couples and married couples.

To sum up a large body of research, there is considerable evidence that marriage protects against depression, especially for mothers, and also that married people have higher relationship quality, on average, compared to cohabitors.

Maggie v. Dr. Keith, in the ring here.

I think she beat him pretty bad, don't you?

Finally, good news from San Diego. The Ruth Institute is hosting a conference, "It Takes a Family to Raise a Village!", for young adults aged 18-30. You don't have to be a student to learn about marriage in beautiful San Diego.

If you're interested, you can get more information, and find the online application here.

Now I have to get back to work. Will we win in New York?

I love the smell of victory in the afternoon.

God bless you and thank you again for your courage and your decency in standing up for God's truth about marriage.

Sincerely,

Brian brown

Brian S. Brown
President
National Organization for Marriage

P.S. Your support makes these victories possible! Please consider what you can give to defend marriage across this nation. Remember that every dollar makes a difference, and helps us make your voice heard in the halls of power!

Listen to NOM's Spanish Radio Ad Promoting Sunday's March to Defend Marriage in NY!

NOM teamed up with NY State Senator Ruben Diaz to produce and air a new Spanish-language ad promoting this Sunday's Rally in Defense of Marriage in the Bronx (details on the march here).

Here is the ad (with English subtitles):

This ad has been airing in local NY markets since May 5th.

New Book: Psychologist Writes of Daughters' Father Hunger

Dr. Peggy Drexler, professor at Cornell Medical School, was interviewed by the Daily Caller about her new book, "Our Fathers, Ourselves":

Of the 75 women Dr. Drexler interviewed, the research psychologist wrote, “No matter how successful they were or how much they had achieved, and no matter how content they were in their own marriages and the families they had formed, they still wanted and in some cases hungered for their fathers’ love and approval.”

... When asked how a fatherless female could seek her non-existent dad’s approval, Dr. Drexler told TheDC, “I believe a maternal and paternal image is hardwired into our unconscious and in that sense primal.

Sports TV Host Fired After Tweeting Support of Marriage!

The Associated Press is reporting out of Canada that a man has been fired from his job after using his personal Twitter account to voice his views on marriage:

A Toronto broadcaster has been fired after he posted on Twitter about the debate surrounding New York Rangers forward Sean Avery's support of same-sex marriage.

Damian Goddard was a host on Rogers Sportsnet. On Tuesday, he tweeted his support for hockey agent Todd Reynolds, who used Twitter to voice his opposition to Avery's position.

Goddard wrote: "I completely and whole-heartedly support Todd Reynolds and his support for the traditional and TRUE meaning of marriage."

In a statement, Sportsnet spokesman Dave Rashford says: "Mr. Goddard was a freelance contractor and in recent weeks it had become clear that he is not the right fit for our organization."

Mind-boggling!

Iowa National Guard Chaplains Won’t Perform Gay Marriages

From the Des Moines Register:

The Iowa National Guard has no plans to have its chaplains perform same-sex unions if the Pentagon decides to recognize openly gay military service later this year, a military spokesman said today

“Per federal law and Department of Defense policy, our chaplains are prohibited from performing same-sex unions or marriages as conducting these types of ceremonies in a duty status would violate the Defense of Marriage Act. At this point we have not received any guidance from the Department of Defense regarding a change in that regulation,” said Col. Gregory Hapgood Jr., the Iowa National Guard’s public affairs officer at Camp Dodge.

Maggie's Column: Dr. Keith Ablow-ing in the wind on marriage?

NOM Chairman Maggie Gallagher's latest column:

IS marriage bad for your mental health? Fox News expert Dr. Keith Ablow says so.

He lauds Cameron Diaz’s claim that marriage is a “dying institution,” and goes on to say that in his clinical judgment “marriage is (as it has been for decades now) a source of real suffering for the vast majority of married people.”

... Dr. Ablow has impressive credentials. His website calls him “one of America’s leading psychiatrists,” and an assistant professor at Tufts Medical School.

But when it comes to marriage, mental health and relationship quality, Dr. Ablow is blowing hot air.

Continue reading at the Manila Times.

Breaking News: Gov. Cuomo says SSM May Not Have the Votes in NY!

This from the AP:

Gov. Andrew Cuomo said Wednesday that a proposal to legalize gay marriage in New York may not reach the state Senate for a debate and vote after all.

"We want to pass a bill," Cuomo said Wednesday. "We don't want to bring up a bill in the Senate that would fail."

He said he won't put the bill to a vote "for the sake of a vote." That was the argument in 2009 by many optimistic advocates who thought bringing the issue to the floor would at least help the effort's momentum, and would force lawmakers to vote their conscience over politics. The surprising defeat in the Senate turned out to be a setback for gay marriage advocates nationwide.

Rhode Island Hispanics Deliver 2,000+ Signatures Against CU Bill

Neither GLAD, nor MERI, nor the Hispanic Ministerial Alliance like this bill.

The latter deliver petitions to RI legislators with 2000+ signatures, we are told from Rhode Island sources.

Breaking News from AP: Civil Unions Bill Flops in Rhode Island

From the AP:

A political compromise calling for the creation of civil unions in Rhode Island has drawn nothing but opposition during a public hearing in the Statehouse...

Civil unions would grant the same state rights given to married couples in Rhode Island. The proposal was introduced after legislative leaders said gay marriage legislation lacked the votes to pass.

The committee could decide as early as next week whether to advance the bill to the full House for consideration.

ADF, NOM, and GLAD All Agree - Civil Union Legislation is a Bad Deal for Rhode Island

In a strange turn of events, the National Organization for Marriage, the Alliance Defense Fund, and Gay and Lesbian Advocates and Defenders all came down on the same side during Rhode Island Judiciary Committee Hearings on Civil Unions (HB 6103) this Wednesday.

Even GLAD was forced to admit they agree with one-man/one-woman legislative champions on this one – Civil Unions legislation before the Rhode Island House is bad law and should be defeated.

Many Committee members remarked that they received 1,000’s of communications against this bill and none in favor.

No witnesses signed up to testify in favor of House Bill 6103. Nonetheless, bill sponsor Representative Petrarca stated he did not care that no one was in support of the bill.

MERI Board President, Martha Holt, declared that she would be the first to volunteer to challenge the proposed civil unions legislation in court. GLAD attorney Karen Lowey agreed that court action is “on the table."