NOM BLOG

Ed Whelan: DOMA and Laws Protecting Marriage Stand and Fall Together

Legal scholar Ed Whelan pushes back against the New York Times in NRO's Bench Memos blog:

“Six federal courts have ruled on the Defense of Marriage Act and reached the same conclusion”—that DOMA is unconstitutional. So declares the New York Times in its house editorial today, in a half-truth that rises above the NYT’s usual level of accuracy. It’s also true, as the House of Representatives’ certiorari petition spells out (on pp. 9-10), that five or so federal courts have rejected the constitutional challenge to DOMA,[...]

... The NYT also states that the “legal challenge over federal benefits [DOMA] is a matter separate from the broader question of whether gay people have a constitutional right to marry.” But, notwithstanding confusion over false federalism interests supposedly implicated by DOMA (see my point 3.b here), I see no plausible basis on which the Court could invalidate DOMA without adopting reasoning that would compel invention of a federal constitutional right to same-sex marriage. So don’t be snookered by the suggestion that the two issues are meaningfully distinct.

In Bid to Oust Pro-SSM McDonald, NY Conservative Party Likely to Back Challenger Marchione

The fall-out from same-sex marriage in New York continues:

State Conservative Party officials will likely back Saratoga County Clerk Kathy Marchione in her state Senate bid, setting the stage for a three-way race for the 43rd district this fall.

Marchione, a Republican looking to unseat Sen. Roy McDonald, R-Saratoga, filed nominating petitions with the state Board of Elections on Wednesday and included the signatures of 458 Conservatives.

... Veitch said even though McDonald received the endorsements of Conservative committees in Rensselaer and Columbia counties, which totaled about 80 percent of the 43rd district’s weighted vote, it was unlikely the senator would receive the vote of the state Conservative Party’s executive committee.

The spokesman stopped short of attributing that to McDonald’s 2011 vote to legalize same-sex marriage, though state Conservative Party Chairman Michael Long said Thursday that party leaders had told all elected officials “anyone who voted to destroy traditional marriage would not receive” the party endorsement.

... McDonald and Marchione appear ready to square off in a September primary for the Republican line, which could prove crucial in the November election. -- The Saratogian

Ruben Diaz: President Obama Has Risked His Re-Election on SSM

New York State Senator Ruben Diaz writes about the political repercussions of supporting SSM:

"...Recent polls indicate that the African-American community in the nation is divided in respect to same-sex marriage. A Pew Center Poll recently found that 63% of African-Americans reject gay marriage and only 37% are in favor. 

This is not the first time that Rev. Williams Owens and the Coalition of African-American pastors have criticized President Barack Obama in response to same-sex marriage. In May, Rev. Owens issued a statement condemning the President for comparing the gay rights movement to the African-American civil rights movement.

In his statement, at that time, Rev. Owens said: “The hijacking of the civil rights movement by homosexuals, bisexuals and gender confused people is unacceptable. There is no legitimate comparison between skin color and sexual behavior.”

I believe that many elected officials will lose constituents and some will lose their seats because of their position in favor of same-sex marriage and the Democratic Party is in danger of losing the majority in the United States Senate and even the President’s re-election could be problematic and all of this because of same-sex marriage."

NAACP Gay Marriage Position Draws Protest From Black Clergy Group

Gene Demby of the Huffington Post reports:

An organization of black clergy members traveled to the NAACP's annual convention in Houston to protest the civil rights group's recent decision to endorse same-sex marriage.

The Coalition of African-American Pastors (CAAP), headed by Rev. William Owens of Memphis, Tenn., said that the NAACP had abandoned its core mission by supporting same-sex marriage.

"This is supposed to be an organization for black people who were beaten, who were mistreated and who were enslaved," Owens told The Huffington Post. "You're advocating for something that's not normal, that's not natural. It's still out of line, it's against moral law."

"Gay marriage is leading us down a bad path," Owens added. "Our young people are already hurt. They're already damaged."

Owens said that the NAACP should focus on issues like unemployment and education, and added that CAAP's online petition in support of "traditional marriage" had garnered at least 5,000 signatures since the group held an initial press conference about its effort last week. He said that he doubted the civil rights group's membership would have backed the resolution.

"If they have taken an issue where they asked members, they would have lost," Owens said. "They had to do it under cloak of darkness."

Leader of Catholic Church in Scotland Doubles-Down in Defense of Marriage

PinkNews.uk (a gay news source):

Speaking in [last week]’s Sunday Times, Cardinal Keith O’Brien warned the Scottish Government that it will face an “unprecedented backlash” from the Catholic Church in Scotland if it goes ahead with plans to legalise same-sex marriage, claiming “marriage is under threat and politicians need to know the Catholic Church will bear any burden and meet any cost in its defence.”

The Catholic Church says it will spend an additional £100,000 on an advertising campaign against the plans, on top of the £50,000 it has already spent against marriage equality in Scotland.

General MacArthur on the Connection Between National Morality and Prosperity

General Douglas MacArthur was the Supreme Commander of the U.S. Army in the Southwest Pacific Arena and was awarded the Medal of Honor.

In his speech to the Cadets at West Point in1962 he shared with them this wisdom:

"In this day of gathering storms, as moral deterioration of political power spreads its growing infection, it is essential that every spiritual force be mobilized to defend and preserve the religious base upon which this nation is founded; for it has been that base which has been the motivating impulse to our moral and national growth. History fails to record a single precedent in which nations subject to moral decay have not passed into political and economic decline. There has been either a spiritual reawakening to overcome the moral lapse, or a progressive deterioration leading to ultimate national disaster."

Brazilian Psychology Association Seeks to Revoke Christian Therapist’s License

LifeSiteNews:

Brazilian psychologists are seeking to revoke the license of a therapist for publicly affirming her Christian beliefs on her online blog and twitter accounts, an action that the organization claims violates its code of ethics.

Marisa Lobo, a psychologist and Evangelical who has published several popular works on psychological issues, sends Twitter messages to her thousands of followers under the title “Christian Psychology,” and maintains a website with the same name.

The Federal Council of Psychology (CFP), which has the power to regulate the activities of psychologists in Brazil, informed Lobo in February through its affiliate in the state of Paraná that she had 15 days to remove any indication of an association between her psychology practice and her religious beliefs from her website, or risk losing her license to practice.

Lobo’s posts and tweets often conflict with the sexually libertine and left-wing ideology espoused by the CFP, including denunciations of homosexual adoption, and support for sexual orientation change therapy. She claims that the process against her was spurred by complaints from homosexuals, especially regarding her opposition to the “gay kit,” a set of highly explicit materials which was to be distributed to children in public schools in 2011 as an “anti-homophobia measure.” However, the program was suspended due to public outrage.

New Poll: Majority of Scots Against Gay Marriage

The UK Christian Institute:

Most people in Scotland want marriage to stay between a man and a woman, latest polling shows.

A majority (55 per cent) agree that “marriage should continue to be defined as a life-long exclusive commitment between a man and a woman”. Only 38 per cent disagree.

And half of all Scots want the matter to be decided by referendum, only 39 per cent want to leave it to MSPs. Support for a referendum is even higher amongst young people.

Maggie Gallagher on Efforts to Silence the Regnerus Study

Cross-posted from NRO's The Corner blog, where Maggie Gallagher originally published it:

Scott Rose, who writes that I have blood on my hands for opposing gay marriage (read this to get a flavor of who Scott Rose is and how he thinks), has filed an ethics complaint charging a serious scholar with “scientific misconduct” for publishing a study in a peer-reviewed scientific journal. The study was incidentally reviewed by three major family sociologists, Paul Amato, Cynthia Osbourne, and David Eggebeen.

Will Saletan’s question about a “Liberal War on Science?” is beginning to look prophetic. Will the academic community react against political attacks on scholarship like this? Or will liberalism trump the guild? Stay tuned.

Marriage Wins Bipartisan Support!, NOM Marriage News

NOM National Newsletter

Dear Marriage Supporter,

Gov. Mitt Romney spoke this week at the 103rd national convention of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP).

A powerful majority of African-Americans are strong Democrats (and economic liberals), so, while I hardly think it is news, the headlines have focused on the fact that the crowd did not like it when Romney said he would repeal Obamacare.

Meanwhile, what was the biggest applause line for Gov. Romney? It was the strong stance he took for marriage, when he said:

A study by the Brookings Institution has shown that for those that graduate from high school, who get a full-time job, and wait until 21 before they marry and then have their first child, the probability of becoming poor is two percent. And if those factors are absent, the probability of being poor is 76%," said Gov. Romney, "Here at the NAACP you understand the deep and lasting difference that family makes. [...] Any policy that lifts up and honors the family is going to be good for the country and that must be our goal. As President I will promote strong families and I will defend traditional marriage.

NAACP members in the audience then gave Gov. Romney more than polite applause in response to his pledge.

 

People try to claim Gov. Romney never speaks about his stand for marriage. Nonsense. Of course he speaks mostly on the economy—we're in real economic trouble—but he has always been a consistent fighter for marriage as one man and one woman, and he re-affirmed that this week in Houston.

While we are on the subject, Texas Gov. Rick Perry also reaffirmed his strong support for marriage this week in an interview with Peter Robinson of the Hoover Institution for the Uncommon Knowledge series over at National Review Online.

Texas is a model for economic issues, governor, but is it also a model for social issues?

Here is what Gov. Perry said in response:

If you are going to base your public service upon your values then you are going to get criticized by those who don't agree with those values. I don't back away from my positions on traditional marriage, on abortion. Those are values, and actually they are values from my perspective, they can't be equivocated. You are either for traditional marriage or you are not. You are either for protecting innocent life or you are not... The issue of traditional marriage is one that continues to bubble forward and I happen to believe that if you are going to have a society that is successful, economically or otherwise, you are going to have to have values that you attach that society to.

For 2000 years we have had marriage between a man and a woman....I suspect that issue is not going to go away, but just because you share a different view, or you are flexible on the issue does not mean that God has changed his mind about it.

 

The warm response by the crowd in the NAACP national convention, whose leadership just endorsed gay marriage, reminds us that it is not just Republicans who support marriage. In fact, Buzzfeed Politics reports that, "One third of House Democrats broke with their leaders today and kept their names off a brief urging a federal appeals court to strike down the Defense of Marriage Act, which limits federal recognition of marriages to those between one man and one woman."

The media does not seem interested in this evidence of dissent within the Democratic party on this issue.

Marriage is an extraordinary issue, politically speaking. It is an issue that unites and ignites a new coalition across old lines of race, creed and color.

Witness another great event for marriage that took place at the NAACP convention just yesterday afternoon.

The Coalition of African American Pastors, headed by Rev. William Owens (who also serves as the NOM outreach coordinator for Black churches), organized a press conference with leading black pastors calling on the NAACP to rescind its endorsement of gay marriage.

Here's Rev. Owens own words on the subject (from a CAAP press release):

"The National Association for the Advancement of Colored People needs to be recalled to its founding purpose," said Rev. William Owens, President of CAAP. "Black people face acute and urgent needs, from unemployment to education, family fragmentation, discrimination and crime.

"We are calling on the NAACP, a beloved organization in our eyes, to reclaim its mission. The Black church founded the NAACP, and it is not the organization for the advancement of gays and lesbians—whatever the merits of that movement. Return to your roots and stand with the Black Church on marriage. The Black Church in our eyes remains the conscience of America.

"To the board of NAACP we say, 'Do not worry about the money, God will provide.' Stand with the Church and the Bible and the natural law, as our brother with whom we marched, Rev. Martin Luther King, Jr., called on us to do."

Wow. And that's not all. After yesterday's press conference Rev. Owens sat down with Megyn Kelly of Fox News to talk about Obama's position on same-sex marriage and why it is putting his support among the African-American community in jeopardy:

 

Our own Thomas Peters put together a great summary of the explosive impact the Coalition of African-American Pastors has had in the last two months, ever since President Obama renounced his view that he supports marriage as one man and one woman "because God is in the mix."

This story which appeared in the Washington Examiner was picked up by the Drudge Report (as you can see at right):

A large coalition of African-American pastors, snubbed by President Obama and Attorney General Eric Holder in their demand for a meeting to discuss same-sex marriage, are calling on blacks to boycott the president and sign a petition demanding that the administration withdraw support for gay marriage.

"By embracing gay marriage, President Obama is leading the country down an immoral path," said Rev. William Owens, president of the 1,300-member Coalition of African-American Pastors. "Some things are bigger than the next election."

...His group also started a petition to encourage Obama to change his mind. It's called 100000signatures4marriage.com.

..."We were once proud of President Obama, but our pride has turned to shame," said Owens.

Numerous other news sites are picking up on this story, including OneNewsNow, USNews & World Report, and the Kansas City Star, which includes this interesting tidbit:

"...Obama rejects the suggestion of specific programs aimed at African-Americans, and the contrast with his recently announced support of same-sex marriage and his executive order halting the deportation of hundreds of thousands of young illegal immigrants strikes some African-Americans as taking them for granted."He can have the gay pride celebration in the White House, he can have Lady Gaga in the White House, and he's in the White House today because of the civil rights movement and the price that was paid for civil rights," said the Rev. William Owens, the president of the Coalition of African-American Pastors, a group that opposes Obama's gay marriage stance. "He has met with the Latinos; he meets with everything except for the people who put him where he is."

These questions will surface again this week, as Obama skips the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People annual convention in Houston."

All this news and coverage prompted Crystal Wright (the "Conservative Black Chick") to write in the Washington Post:

With nothing left in his arsenal and desperate to save his job, Obama has resorted to pandering to black voters, whom he largely has ignored during his presidency Obama is losing ground with black voters among the 95 percent of blacks who voted for him in 2008. Outraged over Obama's support of gay marriage, the Coalition of African American Pastors said they would not support him in 2012. A new poll found Romney would get 20 percent of the black vote in North Carolina if the election was held today.

Meanwhile, Edward Klein, the former editor in chief of the New York Times Magazine writes:

"...Many socially conservative church-going blacks are deeply upset with Obama's endorsement of gay marriage. Recently, the president refused to meet with a group representing the 1,300-member Coalition of African-American Pastors to discuss the group's opposition to same-sex marriage. "By embracing gay marriage, President Obama is leading the country down an immoral path," said the Reverend William Owens, president of the coalition.

...It is Romney, the lily-white presumptive Republican nominee, who is traveling to Houston to make a major speech to this important black audience, while the country's first African-American president is skipping this year's NAACP confab in order to avoid having to confront some uncomfortable questions about the worsening state of black America under his administration."

While the majority of African-American voters will probably overlook his betrayal of marriage and vote for him for other understandable reasons (including pride in his historic achievement of winning the office of President in a country that within living memory shamefully segregated Black people), it is very clear the Black Church is going to push President Obama hard to change his mind on the issue.

African-Americans have been the one constituency in the last few months which President Obama appears to take for granted. Women, gays, and Latinos have all had concrete "gifts" from this administration in the last few months: ending deportations, free contraceptives, switching sides on gay marriage. I pray these leaders, Democrats almost all, will be able to reach the White House and sway the President's heart.

Let me close with some good news.

First, here's the latest video from the Marriage Anti-Defamation Alliance, and you will want to see it!

 

Actor Kirk Cameron, when asked about gay marriage on national TV, answered truthfully and was hit with the full, "What??! How can you say that horrible stuff?!" routine in the media.

Yet he really wants to talk about marriage and faith: "If we want a great future in this world, we have to take God at his Word, and God makes it really clear that society and civilization is really held together by the glue of families—this is where the next generation of human beings are incubated and nurtured and matured.....when a man and a woman come together and they say "I do" they are committing for a lifetime to love each other and to model what love is and what forgiveness is and what joy is to their kids."

As Kirk Cameron said in another venue on where he gets his ideas about marriage. "He speaks with authority on every subject including marriage and His advice trumps Oprah's every time."

Amen to that! (And no offense to Oprah!)

CNBC just released a list of the top ten states for growing businesses. It's yet another nail in the coffin for the absurd argument gay marriage advocates keep promoting that protecting marriage is somehow bad for business.

Top of the list? Texas, followed by Utah, Virginia, North Carolina, North Dakota, Nebraska, South Dakota, Colorado, Georgia, and Wyoming.

None of these states recognize gay marriage. And 9 out 10 have passed marriage amendments. But truth does not seem to be a high priority for a lot of these pro-SSM advocates—if it sounds good, they say it and seem to believe they can make you and I believe it.

But truth does have a way of winning out. The Presbyterians met this week and the media announced they were likely to vote to endorse gay marriage. Instead, just as the Methodists did a month ago, this historic mainline Protestant denomination refused to do so.

A final bit of happy truth for you this week:

Arthur Brooks, a scholar and president of the American Enterprise Institute, crunched the numbers. And when it comes to happiness, here's what he found (from a New York Times Op Ed):

...Whether religion and marriage should make people happy is a question you have to answer for yourself. But consider this: Fifty-two percent of married, religious, politically conservative people (with kids) are very happy—versus only 14 percent of single, secular, liberal people without kids.

People are happy when they feel connected to something larger than themselves: marriage, family, country and faith.

We were made that way by One who knew what He was doing, as Kirk Cameron says.

God Bless you, and thank you for all that you have made possible. You are the glue that holds our work together, that unites and ignites the fire of love and truth now blazing across this great land.

Together we will keep up this great and good fight!

CP: 20,000 Sign Boycott of General Mills Over Gay Marriage

The Christian Post:

What do home improvement supplies, coffee, and cereal have to do with the gay marriage debate? Although at first glance the answer would be nothing, there is a strong connection. General Mills, one of the world's largest food companies, has weighed in on the gay marriage debate, joining Home Depot and Starbucks, among other powerful companies, in support of redefining marriage.

The National Organization for Marriage, a non-profit group that advocates for the protection of traditional marriage, has gathered over 20,000 signatures on its petition against General Mills' public opposition to the marriage amendment in Minnesota this November, which would define marriage as between one man and one woman. Those who signed the petition,Dump General Mills, vowed to boycott the company's products over its position on the marriage issue.

... NOM had previously led a similar campaign against Starbucks that has to date over 45,000 signatures. And last year, the American Family Association rallied over half a million people to commit to boycotting Home Depot over its support of homosexual activism.

Make a pro-marriage statement by signing the pledges at www.dumpstarbucks.com and www.dumpgeneralmills.com.

Forbes Brand Index: Republicans Sour on Starbucks After SSM Endorsement

Forbes has a monthly Red/Blue series where they "investigate how consumer political affiliation relates to brand perception." Here's what they found about Starbucks:

Democrats and Republicans started the year with a marginally different perception of the brand: a Buzz score of 15.7 for blue and 14.6 for red. Fast forward to this week, and perception is at 19.3 for blue and 10.7 for red – both scores are positive, but there is a definite partisan divide. The perception is measured by YouGov BrandIndex’s Buzz score, which asks respondents: “Have you heard anything positive or negative about this brand?”

... we see partisanship at work in the coffee chain’s perception. Earlier in 2012, the brand led some right-wing consumers to go elsewhere for their daily cup of Joe after it supported a gay marriage bill. Joining fellow Northwest-based firms Microsoft and Nike, the company said in January that it was: “Proud to join other leading Northwest employers in support of Washington state legislation recognizing marriage equality for same-sex couples.” The conservative group National Organization for Marriage launched a “Dump Starbucks” campaign in response to the coffeehouse’s decision. Perception after the statement consistently increased for Democrat consumers and decreased among Republicans.

Video: Dr. Keith Ablow on Threats Against Those Trying to Do Good Science on Gay Parenting

Here is the video interview with Fox News Studio B where Dr. Keith Ablow admits he hesitates to write about same-sex parenting and related issues because every time he does he gets threats (see our related NOMblog story here).

After explaining the new research on same-sex parenting, Dr. Ablow says:

"...these are concerning data, that have to be investigated, and I know how controversial it is but as a doctor, as somebody who cares about science, you can't dismiss numbers that come across as compelling as these do."

And later in the interview:

"...it's such a controversial thing [talking about this issue], I have to tell you I hesitate to write the blog. Because every time I do I get threats -- no I get threats, people come, they're going to come to my office, they're going to burn down my house, it's incredible ... in this politically correct insane environment, citing data doesn't seem to be compelling enough, because there's a lot of hatred."

Watch the whole segment:

Rev. Bill Owens to Megyn Kelly: Obama Is Taking the Black Vote for Granted

Rev. Bill Owens consults with NOM as a liaison to the black churches. Here he is talking to Megyn Kelly on Fox News about Obama's position on same-sex marriage and why it is putting his support among the African-American community in jeopardy:

Romney Leads Obama Among Married Voters 51%-38%

FoxNews:

All the single ladies ... seem to really like President Obama.

A new Quinnipiac University poll shows Obama has a 2-to-1 advantage over Mitt Romney among single women in the 2012 presidential race. In fact, the survey underscores the so-called "marriage gap" between the two opponents -- in general, single voters favor Obama while married voters favor the Republican candidate.

According to the poll, married voters back Romney 51-38 percent. Single voters, though, back Obama 54-34 percent. The gap is much wider among single women -- 60 percent for Obama, 31 percent for Romney