NOM BLOG

Chairman of MN for Marriage: "Campaign Finance Board Oversteps Its Authority"

John Helmberger is the chairman of the Minnesota for Marriage campaign. He writes in the Star-Tribune:

The Star Tribune waxes righteous ("Voters should know amendment donors," Oct. 6) that the Minnesota Campaign Finance Board has "made the right call" in a ruling that attempts to force nonprofit organizations to disclose the identity of supporters if the nonprofit group contributes to the marriage-amendment campaign.

Nobody disagrees that voters are entitled to know who contributes to the marriage campaign. But the changes the Campaign Finance Board proposes are not authorized by law and would mislead the public, resulting in the disclosure of people who did not contribute to the campaign.

... the board simply does not have the legal authority to arbitrarily change Minnesota campaign reporting laws. That is the job of the Legislature. For almost a decade, the board has been asking the Legislature to expand or change the definition of "association" to be able to regulate nonprofit corporations in this manner, and the Legislature refused to grant it. The board has acted illegally in claiming legal authority it does not possess.

Local Media Asks Did Money Sway Grisanti's Flip-Flop on Marriage?

Senator Grisanti is "feeling the heat", Local News 4 reports:

Bravo, marriage defenders! Your efforts are helping us put on notice the Albany politicians who betrayed marriage for money!

Illinois Senator Introduces Bill to Allow Religious-Based Foster Care to Continue

The State-Journal Register:

Catholic Charities would be able to continue its foster care and adoption services without serving same-sex couples under legislation introduced this week by state Sen. Kyle McCarter.

The bill would amend the Illinois Religious Freedom Protection and Civil Union Act to allow religious-based child-welfare agencies and those operated or owned by a religious organization to refer such couples to the Illinois Department of Children and Family Services for other adoption and foster care options.

McCarter, R-Lebanon, introduced the legislation in response to an ongoing legal battle between Catholic Charities agencies and the state after the civil union law took effect June 1.

“I do believe that if it’s sent to the floor, there’s enough votes to pass it in the House and the Senate,” McCarter said Friday. “Catholic Charities is responsible for a majority of adoptions and placements of foster kids in southern Illinois, and they do it for a fraction of the cost, and they do it with an extreme amount of compassion.”

John Boehner, U.S. House Step Forward to Defend DOMA

FoxNews:

Gays and lesbians are not entitled to the same heightened legal protection and scrutiny against discrimination as racial minorities and women in part because they are far from politically powerless and have ample ability to influence lawmakers, lawyers for a U.S. House of Representatives group said in a federal court filing.

... "A spate of recent news stories only confirms the conclusion that homosexuals are far from politically powerless," the filing reads.

... "gays and lesbians cannot be labeled `politically powerless' without draining that phrase of all meaning," it says, arguing that the court should deny Golinski's motion for summary judgment in her favor.

The administration [has] characterized gays and lesbians as minorities with limited political power. It had previously said it would not defend the marriage act.

The House's Bipartisan Legal Advisory Group has stepped in to defend it.

CA Schools Scrambling to Implement SB48, As Parents and Teachers Seek to Opt Out

The Los Angeles Times:

...teachers and administrators are flummoxed about how to carry out a new law requiring California public schools to teach all students — from kindergartners to 12th graders — about lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender Americans in history classes.

"At this point, I wouldn't even know where to begin," Principal Don Wilson said.

... The law has sparked confusion about what, exactly, is supposed to be taught. Will fourth-graders learn that some of the Gold Rush miners were gay and helped build San Francisco? Will students be taught about the "two-spirited people" tradition among some Native Americans, as one gay historian mused?

School districts will have little help in navigating this sensitive and controversial change, which has already prompted some parents to pull their children out of public schools.

... Calvary Chapel Corona — an evangelical Christian church of 1,200 congregants in western Riverside County — is an active opponent [of SB58]. At least seven families pulled their children from public schools in protest.

"This law teaches children that it's OK to be gay, and that's not my Christian values," said Bryan Breuer, who withdrew his children from public schools. "I don't understand trying to force this on my children."

Grace R. Callaway, a public school teacher near Yuba City, said she will refuse to teach LGBT issues to her fifth- and sixth-graders because she believes homosexuality is a "destructive lifestyle."

... How administrators plan to handle "conscientious objectors" like Callaway is unclear.

New Colorado Group Forms to Counter Tim Gill Political Machine

The Denver Post:

A new conservative political group formed to highlight economic issues has unveiled its first endeavor — automated calls ripping an education tax measure on the Nov. 1 ballot.

Compass Colorado was formed to blunt liberal group ProgressNow and similar efforts in the state, said Compass president Tyler Houlton.

"The days of conservatives putting up a haphazard front against the liberals' well-oiled Colorado machine are officially over," he said.

After an initial blitz against Proposition 103, the group expects to be very involved in state and federal economic issues, Houlton said.
Compass Colorado is the latest conservative group formed to counter the liberal movement that includes ProgressNow Colorado and wealthy donors such as Pat Stryker and Tim Gill.

CNS: Same-Sex Marriage Deepens Concern for Religious Liberty

Dennis Sadowski at Catholic News Service:

The widening campaign by gay rights advocates to promote same-sex marriage as a civil rights issue is forcing Catholic and other religious institutions to confront charges of intolerance and discrimination.

Also at risk, say church officials working on the legal front, is the way religious institutions and individuals opposed to same-sex marriage conduct business from hall rentals to receiving government contracts for social services.

... "The general issue is the definition of marriage creates many, many rights, not just one," explained Anthony R. Picarello Jr., general counsel for the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops. "So changing the definition of marriage creates changes throughout the legal system."

... "Redefining marriage has a multiplier effect," Picarello explained to Catholic News Service. "The problems proliferate. The problems that we see under mere sexual orientation anti-discrimination laws multiply by order of magnitude when marriage is redefined.

"Marriage is a legal lever, because in our society we have a legal infrastructure that rewards those who support marriage, and punishes those who oppose it. When that legal structure ... is then applied to a relationship that isn't marriage, the people who object to that definition are going to suffer severe disadvantages," he added.

Four GOP Senators Get Forty Pieces of Silver

The New York Times reports:

This week, the four Republican state senators who provided the decisive votes to pass the marriage bill are to get a big financial boost from those donors, including Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg. A fund-raiser planned for Thursday night in Manhattan is expected to raise about $1.25 million to help finance their re-election bids next year.

And yet, The Times also reports that $1.5 million poured into David Weprin's campaign could not save him from the voters come election day:

Democrats poured $1.5 million into their failed attempt to retain the Congressional seat last held by Anthony D. Weiner, vastly outspending the Republican candidate, Bob Turner, who ultimately prevailed in New York’s Ninth District.

NOM's own flash poll the day of the election showed more than 90 percent of Orthodox Jews (about 13 percent of all voters in the district) voted for Bob Turner, and 72 percent of these said his vote for gay marriage influenced their decision to oppose him.

Voters in this Democratic district said they opposed gay marriage 50 percent to 38 percent, and of those who agree marriage is the union of husband and wife, 44% said Weprin's position was a factor in their vote, while just 29% of the minority of those who disagree said his position was a factor.

The more than $1.5 million the Democrats spent could not save David Weprin's from his constituents. We predict Mayor Bloomberg's money from this week's fundraiser to protect pro-gay marriage Republicans will be similarly futile in 2012.

Bottom line ... yes, money matters. But voters matter more!

Related on the NOM blog: "Four New York Senators and Their Same-Sex Marriage Money Dance"

Michigan Seeks to Protect Counselors’ Rights

CitizenLink:

As the case of Julea Ward, a graduate student expelled from Eastern Michigan University for referring to another counselor a lesbian seeking help with her same-sex relationship, wends its way through the federal courts, Michigan legislators are considering a bill to keep others from suffering the same way in the future.

On Oct. 5 — one day after Ward’s case was heard by a three-judge panel of the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals — state Rep. Joe Haveman introduced HB 5040, a bill specifically protecting the religious liberties of counseling students at public universities. A similar bill is being shepherded through the Senate by Minority Floor Leader Tupac A. Hunter.

Michigan Family Forum Director Brad Snavely said legislators hope to pass a bill this autumn. He also was on hand for the arguments at the 6th Circuit, and said the panel seemed favorable to Ward.

Local TV on Sen. Grisanti's Concern Over LTPV Billboards

Despite attending fundraisers with pro-SSM millionaires in New York City, local News 4 reports Sen. Grisanti is preparing for a "bruising re-election battle" in Western New York:

Santorum Responds To Cain's Refusal To Defend Marriage

On Meet the Press with David Gregory this weekend Hermain Cain said:

MR. GREGORY: [...] Same sex marriage. Would you seek a constitutional ban for same sex marriage?

MR. CAIN: I wouldn't seek a constitutional ban for same sex marriage, but I am pro traditional marriage.

MR. GREGORY: But you would let the states make up their own mind as they're doing now?

MR. CAIN: They would make up their own minds, yes.

Rick Santorum responded in a press release:

"I have been a long-time advocate for states' rights. However, I believe as Abraham Lincoln did - that states don't have the rights to legalize moral wrongs. Mr. Cain, Congresswoman Bachmann and Governor Perry all believe 50 different definitions of marriage is fine, I strongly disagree and will continue fighting for traditional marriage between one man and woman."

... Senator Santorum is one of the original sponsors of the Federal Marriage Amendment and the nation's leading advocate for the traditional American family. As a presidential candidate, Senator Santorum proudly signed the National Organization for Marriage's "Pro-Marriage Pledge," which Mr. Cain refused to sign. Last fall, Senator Santorum was the only 2012 presidential contender to travel to Iowa and campaign in opposition to Iowa State Supreme Court Justices who decided to take it upon themselves to redefine marriage.

SacBee on NOM Chairman John Eastman: "A New General in the Marriage War"

Dan Morain writes at the Sacramento Bee:

After failing to get elected California attorney general last year, John Eastman, a conservative law professor, has emerged as a different sort of general, one taking a lead in the cultural war over marriage.

Eastman, 51, has been appointed chairman of the National Organization for Marriage, the main organization advocating at the ballot box and in courts for traditional marriage, and against any effort to legalize same-sex marriage.

Eastman, who teaches at Chapman University School of Law in Orange County, regularly files arguments before the U.S. Supreme Court and appellate courts on the hot-button social issues of the day.

His selection underscores that the issue of same-sex marriage is headed to the U.S. Supreme Court. When it finally arrives there, he almost surely will have filed one of the briefs.

Is Reading the Bible on TV Hate Speech? Canadian Human Rights Commission Asked to Decide

LifeSiteNews:

A case argued before the Supreme Court yesterday, if decided the wrong way, could result in “a virtual open season on anyone communicating a religiously informed position on any matter of public policy,” according to Don Hutchinson, general legal counsel for the Evangelical Fellowship of Canada, which intervened in the case - Saskatchewan Human Rights Commission (SHRC) v. William Whatcott.

... The SHRC brought Whatcott before the Saskatchewan Human Rights Tribunal in 2006 over his practice of distributing flyers about the dangers of abortion and homosexuality.

...In an interview with LifeSiteNews today, Hutchinson said that he was “really thrown off” when counsel for Saskatchewan human rights commission, the body charged with assessing what constitutes hate speech under the provincial act, said that reading certain of the writings of Paul from the Scriptures on television would be hate speech.

Grisanti Attacks NOM For Criticizing His Taking Billionaires' Money For Betraying Voters

Buffalo News:

Grisanti called [NOM] "hypocritical" because, he said, it would have been donating to him had he voted against the [SSM] bill.

... Grisanti sought to portray the fundraiser as an afterthought. He said he had to be in New York for a hearing of his environmental conservation committee today, so he went down a day early for the event Bloomberg hosted.

... Asked if he thought there was a connection between his vote and the fundraiser, Grisanti said, "I don't know if there's a connection or not."

... "We already know that Sen. Grisanti lacks even a basic shred of integrity," said Brian Brown, president of the National Organization for Marriage. He said Grisanti signed a vow in 2008 to oppose gay marriage rights and took his group's political donations that year.

"We're very confident that come next election, Sen. Grisanti won't be able to lie to the people anymore and vote against his own constituents because he'll no longer be serving as senator," Brown said today.

NJ School Officials Investigate Teacher Over Expressing Her Views on Homosexuality on Facebook

The Star-Ledger:

School officials in Union Township are investigating allegations that a teacher at Union High School posted comments on her Facebook site criticizing a school display recognizing Lesbian Gay Bisexual and Transgender History Month and calling homosexuality ["a perverted spirit that has existed from the beginning of creation."]

On Saturday, a local attorney who said he had initially been contacted by a parent, wrote to the district calling for the teacher’s dismissal.

... "Hateful public comments from a teacher cannot be tolerated," wrote Paragano, also a former Union Township Municipal Court judge. "She has a right to say it. But she does not have a right to keep her job after saying it."

... Garden State Equality, a gay rights group, joined the lawyer Paragano in calling for the teacher’s dismissal.

"Teachers are supposed to be role models for our children, not hatemongers," said Steven Goldstein, who chairs the group.